Highlands, NJ: Community Guide
Local Knowledge. Shore Results.
Climbing the North Tower of the Twin Lights, twin brownstone lighthouses built in 1862, sitting 250 feet above Sandy Hook Bay, is a normal way to spend an evening here, and you can see the Manhattan skyline with nothing more than your own eyes, no binoculars needed. Highlands sits on some of the highest, most historically significant terrain on the entire Atlantic coast, a genuine strategic lookout point used since long before European settlement, when a beacon burned whale oil on Lighthouse Hill to warn of approaching French ships in 1746.
The Twin Lights themselves carry a remarkable list of firsts: the first twin lighthouse in the country, the first to use a Fresnel lens, one of the first electrically lit seacoast lighthouses in America, and the site where Guglielmo Marconi first demonstrated wireless telegraph technology in 1899, transmitting America's Cup race results to the New York Herald before any other method could. Walt Whitman wrote about his visits here in a set of poems called "Fancies at Navesink," and James Fenimore Cooper drew on Highlands for his novel Water Witch. Gertrude "Trudy" Ederle belongs on that same list of names tied to the town. Her family summered in Highlands, and it's in these waters that her father taught her to swim as a girl, years before she became the first woman to swim the English Channel in 1926, beating the existing men's record in the process.
I'm Matt Quinn, a lifelong Ocean County resident and Jersey Shore agent with United Real Estate Associates. I'm a retired police officer and a former health inspector. I also spent a decade in code enforcement and hold certification as a zoning official, so I know these towns from the inside, not from listing photos. I'll give you the honest version of a place, not the postcard, and tell you when a town isn't the right fit.
Highlands at a Glance
Highlands sits in northern Monmouth County's Bayshore region, on a high bluff overlooking Sandy Hook, Sandy Hook Bay, and the entrance to New York Harbor, the borough's name comes directly from that elevated geography. The population sits around 4,600-4,900, and the town has functioned as a genuine commuter destination for New York since ferry service began in the late 1980s, connecting Highlands directly to Manhattan by water.
The defining fact for buyers: Highlands took one of the hardest hits on the entire Jersey coast during Hurricane Sandy in 2012. A nearly ten-foot storm surge destroyed or severely damaged an estimated 1,250 of the town's roughly 1,500 homes, a genuinely catastrophic event that reshaped the town's approach to flood resilience, with engineers later projecting that elevating downtown Highlands by 8 to 10 feet would cost $25 to $30 million.
What Makes Highlands Different
Landmarks: The Twin Lights Historic Site, a National Historic Landmark since 2006, remains Highlands' defining feature, a free museum and climbable lighthouse with genuinely unmatched views of Sandy Hook and the New York skyline. The Highlands-Sea Bright Bridge connects the borough directly to shore towns south, replacing a long history of ferries and drawbridges dating back to 1872. Hartshorne Woods Park offers substantial hiking and mountain biking terrain on the same high, wooded hills that gave the town its name.
Most desirable pockets: Homes on or near the bluff overlooking Sandy Hook Bay command the clearest views and premium, though buyers should weigh that elevation against the flood risk that affects the lower downtown differently than the hillside. The downtown waterfront area, closest to marinas and restaurants, offers walkability at the cost of being within the zone hit hardest by Sandy.
Defining character: Highlands is defined by dramatic, historically significant elevation paired with a genuine, hard-earned resilience story, a small Bayshore town that has weathered real catastrophic damage and rebuilt with real intention around flood mitigation and community identity.
Is Highlands the Right Fit for You?
Highlands fits buyers who want genuine maritime history, dramatic coastal views, and a real small-town waterfront character, combined with a workable connection to New York via nearby ferry service (from neighboring Atlantic Highlands) and the Highlands-Sea Bright Bridge for southern shore access. It particularly suits buyers who value authentic, lived-in local culture, locals greeting each other by name at spots like Bahrs Landing and Waterwitch Grocer & Gourmet, over a manufactured resort feel.
It's a difficult fit for anyone risk-averse about flooding. Highlands' Hurricane Sandy history is genuinely severe, and buyers should approach any downtown or waterfront property with real, specific flood-zone and elevation diligence rather than general reassurance. Buyers should also understand that Sandy Hook itself, while functionally connected to Highlands and often associated with its identity, is a separate federal recreation area, not technically part of the borough.
What It's Really Like to Live in Highlands
Daily life here genuinely centers on the water and the hills above it, a walk along the waterfront past working marinas, coffee shops, and restaurants, or up toward Lighthouse Hill for the view and a piece of real, tangible history. Local businesses have real, specific identities residents mention by name: Bahrs Landing, Sea & Sand, The Farmacie, Waterwitch Grocer & Gourmet, and Gems Bagels among them.
The town's community calendar reflects its close-knit, rebuilding character, a St. Patrick's Day Parade, Clam Fest, Oktoberfest, farmers markets, and waterfront festivals bring residents together year-round. In August 2026, that calendar includes Trudy Fest, a free, family-friendly celebration at Veterans Park marking the 100th anniversary of Gertrude "Trudy" Ederle's English Channel swim, complete with live music, food trucks, and a kids' zone built around her legacy, a genuine point of hometown pride rather than a manufactured tourist event. Newer redevelopment projects like Scenic Highlands are also adding homes and walkable streets while local voices work to preserve the town's specific character in the process.
Schools & Everyday Family Life
Younger students attend Highlands Elementary School locally, pre-kindergarten through 6th grade, before moving into Henry Hudson Regional School for 7th through 12th grade, part of the same tri-district system serving neighboring Atlantic Highlands. Families should confirm current program details directly given the district's relatively recent regional consolidation.
What to Know Before Making the Move
Hurricane Sandy's damage here was genuinely severe, and flood risk remains a real, central consideration. Roughly 1,250 of the town's 1,500 homes were destroyed or severely damaged in 2012, get specific, current flood-zone and elevation information for any property, particularly in the downtown and waterfront areas.
Sandy Hook is not technically part of Highlands. While functionally connected and closely associated with the town's identity and economy, Sandy Hook is a federal recreation area under separate jurisdiction, worth understanding clearly if beach access specifically factored into your decision.
Ferry commuting to New York typically runs through neighboring Atlantic Highlands, not a dedicated Highlands terminal, confirm the actual commute logistics for a specific address before assuming direct ferry access.
Ongoing redevelopment (like Scenic Highlands) is actively reshaping parts of town. Confirm current construction status and how it may affect a specific property or neighborhood before buying. As a certified zoning officer, I'd recommend confirming current zoning directly with the borough before assuming what's planned for a specific block.
Common Questions About Living in Highlands
Is Highlands at risk of flooding? Yes, genuinely, the town suffered catastrophic damage during Hurricane Sandy, and flood risk remains a real, central factor for downtown and waterfront properties specifically. Elevation and flood-zone diligence matter enormously here.
What are the Twin Lights? A pair of historic 1862 lighthouses on Lighthouse Hill in Highlands, notable for numerous technological firsts, including the first Fresnel lens installation in the country and the site of Marconi's first practical wireless telegraph demonstration.
Is Sandy Hook part of Highlands? Not technically. Sandy Hook is a separate federal recreation area, though it's closely connected to Highlands both physically and in local identity.
How's the commute to New York from Highlands? Workable via ferry service, though the primary terminal serving this stretch of Bayshore is in neighboring Atlantic Highlands, confirm actual logistics directly.
Who was Trudy Ederle, and why does Highlands celebrate her? Gertrude "Trudy" Ederle learned to swim in Highlands as a girl, where her family summered, before becoming the first woman to swim the English Channel in 1926, beating the existing men's record. The town marked the 100th anniversary of that swim with Trudy Fest, a free waterfront celebration at Veterans Park in August 2026.
A Local Perspective on Living Here
Longtime residents describe Highlands' identity through genuine resilience, a town that has weathered real catastrophic storm damage and rebuilt with intention, without losing the small, tight-knit character that made it worth rebuilding in the first place. The dramatic elevation and maritime history aren't marketing angles here; they're lived, daily facts of a town that's occupied some of the most strategically and scenically significant terrain on the Jersey coast for centuries, and that produced, in Trudy Ederle, a young woman who trained in its harbor and went on to break a world record that had stood for men and women alike.
Thinking About Moving to Highlands?
If Highlands' history and views appeal to you but flood risk gives you pause, neighboring Atlantic Highlands offers similarly dramatic elevation with somewhat different flood exposure depending on the specific property, while Middletown Township (which includes Sandy Hook itself) offers a larger, more varied alternative nearby.
Towns with a real storm history like Highlands reward buyers who ask specific, uncomfortable questions about flood risk upfront instead of falling for the view. Ask me the flood questions before you fall for the view.
Ready to Talk It Through?
If you'd rather just talk it through than read another page, grab 30 minutes on my calendar and we'll go through it directly, no pressure, no obligation. Book a free 30-minute call →
Search Homes for Sale in Highlands
Want to see what's actually on the market right now? Search current Highlands listings →
Market Report
Want the bigger picture, active listings, homes under contract, and what's actually sold recently? View the Highlands Market Report →
Compare Nearby Communities
Want to see how Highlands stacks up against a specific town, not just these neighbors? Run the comparison yourself →